Naftule Brandwein: King of the Klezmer Clarinet
Blog by Rene Meyers
The man on stage turned his back to the room. Around his neck hung a neon sign that spelled out his own name, The Naftule Brandwein Orchestra. With his face hidden, he lifted the clarinet and played. The crowd could not see his fingers. That was the trick. Some nights he went even further and pulled down his pants. Other nights he wore an Uncle Sam costume strung with Christmas lights, which once shorted out when he sweated and nearly electrocuted him. Colleagues fumed. And through all the noise, the clarinet sang.
Naftule Brandwein was born on September 20, 1884, in the town of Przemyslany, in Austro-Hungarian Galicia. Today that town lies in Ukraine. Some older sources give 1889 as his birth year. The 1884 date comes from his own 1912 declaration of intention to become a citizen, so we will use it here. He was born into a dynasty. His family belonged to a line of klezmer musicians linked to the Stretiner Hasidic dynasty, which was founded by Rabbi Yehuda Hirsch Brandwein of Stratin.
Music was the family trade. His father, Peysekhe, played violin and clarinet and worked as a badkhn, a wedding jester who made up rhymes on the spot to entertain the guests. His brothers played too. Moyshe played violin, French horn, and valve trombone. Mendel played piano. Leyzer played drums. Azriel played cornet, and he became Naftule’s first teacher. The lessons stuck. One biography says Naftule was one of fourteen children from his father’s four marriages. Another biography counts thirteen sons. The family was large, and the numbers do not agree.
In 1909, Naftule left. He had married a woman named Dora, and their first son, Moses, was born shortly before they sailed. Ship records show Naftule arriving in New York in April 1909, although some sources say 1908. He had left from Hamburg. He was heading for his brother Israel, who already lived on Rivington Street on the Lower East Side. Naftule, Dora, and baby Moses settled nearby, on Pitt Street.
It helps to picture that neighborhood. The Lower East Side of 1909 was one of the most crowded places in America. Yiddish theaters, cafes, and wedding halls lined its streets, and every simcha needed a band. A clarinetist as good as Naftule had work. He filed for citizenship in 1912 and took the Anglicized name Nathan. On stage, though, he stayed Naftule. He became a naturalized citizen in 1919. Some of his relatives remained in Europe. According to one biography, two of his brothers, Eli and Tzvi-Hirsch, never left, and both were murdered by the Nazis. The same biography says that Tzvi-Hirsch’s son, Leopold Kozlowski, later became a leader in bringing klezmer music back to life in Poland.
By the time Naftule landed in New York, he was already a master. He was also a promoter. He knew how to sell himself, and he built a reputation as both a klezmer and a bandleader. But he did not rush into the recording studio. Other klezmer musicians were making records during World War I, among them Abe Elenkrig and Max Leibowitz. Naftule seems to have waited until about 1920. His first recordings were as an uncredited clarinet soloist in the band of Abe Schwartz. Schwartz was a Romanian-born violinist and composer, and he ran many of the recording sessions for Columbia Records that preserved the klezmer sound of the time.
In 1922, Naftule began recording under his own name at Columbia. He cut klezmer dances and long, wandering improvisations called doinas. He also made a few discs of Ukrainian music. In early 1923, he made a handful of records for Emerson and then moved to Columbia’s rival, Victor. From 1923 to 1927, he made about two dozen recordings for Victor, most of them virtuoso klezmer pieces released under the name Naftule Brandwein Orchestra. These were the years when his sound took shape. Writers credit these years with creating the sound of the solo klezmer clarinet in America.
One tune deserves a special mention. It is called Firn di Mekhutonim Aheym, which means Escorting the In-Laws Home. It is a street song, and Abe Schwartz is credited as its composer. Naftule played the clarinet on Schwartz’s 1923 recording, and a recording by Naftule’s own orchestra from that year is also known. A few writers call it Naftule’s own composition, but the record credits point to Schwartz. The clarinet part is a long, singing legato line, full of glides and sobbing ornaments. Musicians who revived klezmer in the 1970s and 1980s fell in love with it, and it is still played today by bands that perform the small-band repertoire of the 1920s.
Naftule was known for much more than his technique. He was known for his wild, impatient way of living. People said he loved to drink and to gamble, and that you had to keep him happy if you wanted him to play all night. A story that has been repeated for decades says he was the favorite musician of Murder, Inc., the Jewish and Italian crime syndicate of Brooklyn. It is a colorful claim, and writers usually say allegedly when they repeat it. We can say only that it is part of the legend.
He loved costumes and surprises. He mixed the many strands of Eastern European Jewish music, which carried echoes of Greek, Turkish, Hungarian, and Romani sounds. His playing jumped up and down the scale. It was full of trills, slides, and little cries. He is often compared to the other great klezmer clarinetist of his day, Dave Tarras, who had a different sound and a different feel for phrasing. Naftule took risks. He often improvised a completely different version of a passage every time he played it.
His behavior was hard on his colleagues. The same antics that delighted a crowd could drive other musicians to fury, and he could not stay with one band for long. Even so, he played in the Yiddish-American Jazz Band of Joseph Cherniavsky, a popular vaudeville act, and in the orchestra of Abe Schwartz. A photograph in the YIVO Institute archive shows him with Cherniavsky’s band around 1924.
Then the music changed. From the mid-1920s on, listeners drifted toward newer, smoother sounds. His Victor sessions ended in 1927. A man who had once been the top klezmer in New York found himself playing the Borscht Belt hotels in the Catskills. One account says he went from the top musician in New York to playing the Borscht Belt. What we know is that he kept working. He took gigs at weddings, parties, and hotels for years.
In 1941, he walked back into the Victor studio. He recorded a handful of tunes under the name Nifty Brandwein, including a piece called Naftule’s Freylekhs and another called Nifty’s Eygene, which means What Belongs to Nifty. Listeners often hear a calmer and more thoughtful player on these records, a man older than the wild young virtuoso of the 1920s. By the 1950s, jobs were harder to find. Naftule could not read sheet music, and he was less at home with American popular songs than some of his contemporaries, such as Dave Tarras. Younger musicians, including Sam Musiker, handled the new demands more easily. Still, he kept working until shortly before he died.
Naftule Brandwein died on October 2, 1963, at age 79. He had been born in 1884, so that age fits. The date falls on the 14th of Tishrei in the Hebrew calendar, the day before the festival of Sukkot begins. He was buried at Mount Hebron Cemetery in Flushing, Queens, in the section of the Progressive Musical Benevolent Society, a mutual aid society for musicians. Cemetery records list him as Nathan Brandwein.
He did not live to see the revival. In the 1970s, a new generation of young musicians began to search for the old klezmer sound, and they found it on scratchy records made decades before. Many of them found Naftule. Players such as David Krakauer, Hankus Netsky, Alicia Svigals, and Michael Winograd have named him as a major influence. Along with Dave Tarras, Israel J. Hochman, Max Leibowitz, and Harry Kandel, he helped shape an American klezmer sound that slowly grew into a big-band style. A hundred years later, his records are still a main source for people who want to hear the old style.
At Mount Hebron, the cemetery calls him Nathan. The labels on his Victor records call him Naftule. The musicians who came after him just call him the king. Somewhere, a young clarinetist is putting on one of his old records, and a sliding, laughing, impossible note rises out of the speaker, and she starts to play it back.
May his memory be a blessing.
Works Cited
“Brandwein, Naftule (1889–1963).” Institut Européen des Musiques Juives, www.iemj.org/en/brandwein-naftule-1889-1963/. Accessed 17 Nov. 2026.
“Columbia Matrix 89008. Fihren Die Mechutonim Aheim / Abe Schwartz’s Orchestra; Naftule Brandwein.” Discography of American Historical Recordings, University of California, Santa Barbara, adp.library.ucsb.edu. Accessed 17 Nov. 2026.
“Naftule Brandwein.” Wikipedia, Wikimedia Foundation, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naftule_Brandwein. Accessed 17 Nov. 2026.
“Naftule Brandwein: King of the Klezmer Clarinet.” Mount Hebron Cemetery, www.mounthebroncemetery.com/legacy/stories/view/?id=149. Accessed 17 Nov. 2026.
“Rockin’ the Shtetl.” New Music USA, newmusicusa.org/?p=272319. Accessed 17 Nov. 2026.
“The Rise of Yiddish Swing.” StoryCorps, storycorps.org/?p=86683. Accessed 17 Nov. 2026.
“Victor Matrix B-27890. Doina / Naftule Brandwein.” Discography of American Historical Recordings, University of California, Santa Barbara, adp.library.ucsb.edu. Accessed 17 Nov. 2026.